I love reading about the intersection between writing and real life; it's fascinating how memory and dream and the other raw materials of living get composted into fiction. But writers and readers have a hard time talking about it for some reason. As if writing is supposed to be purer, or maybe just more straight forward than all that, no one knows how to categorize the experience. Perhaps we are uncomfortable with alchemy here in the modern world. Or maybe we're just uncomfortable with things we can't label easily. Still, it's a silly discussion. As N. once said, "Writers need to stop denying their work is autobiographical and readers need to stop asking if it is." Colson Whitehead has been pretty open about how he used his own childhood as a broad template for his last novel "Sag Harbor". But even he gets a little snippy when he comes face to face with the question:
How is Benji different from you?
I tend not to act or feel or talk in a way that would add anything worthwhile to an extended work of fiction. I tend not to do things that lend themselves to dramatic unity, aesthetic harmony, and narrative discharge. My leitmotifs are crappy. I need an editor or someone of artistic bent to shape my useless existence into something that would interest other people. Also, I am a real person.
I can see him at his computer punching the keys in a furious rhythm, smirking and barking to himself in triumph. "That should shut them up once and for all!"
what a surprise, mr. moose! xoxox
ReplyDeleteI also feel sorry for authors being interviewed - always the same questions and the inevitable personal probing.
ReplyDeleteStill lovin' the hair xxxxx
"I'm a real person" = "Bite me, moron"! Nicely done!
ReplyDeleteI suppose writing is an alternative personal reality... a'what if I'd done this instead of that' kind of thing.
ReplyDeleteAnyhow, whatever, thank goodness for stories!
Sx
Is it real or is it construct?
ReplyDeleteDon't ask, don't tell!
Funny because for me, E@L and I ARE E@L (plus Bruce)!
ReplyDeletelulu...thanks, sugar! i'm really happy i did it! xoxox
ReplyDeleteSo I went to my blog this morning and was cursing Blogspot for not saving my last post...Oops. Sorry for posting accidentally!
ReplyDeleteI still think of blogging as the one place I can finish a sentence...without being interrupted. :)
ReplyDeleteThere will always be some amount of autobiography in fiction; after all, a writer writes about what he or she knows best. I don't believe there is such a thing as objective fiction.
ReplyDeletePerhaps the best example I can think of in modern autobiographical fiction is James Lee Burke.
This is a really good post.
ReplyDeleteSomething I think about a lot.
I would die if someone asked me a question like that about a character I'd written, mostly because I have no idea where I end and my characters begin.
ReplyDeleteWrite what you know! Be it recipes or eulogies or memories of a time long ago. Passion comes through in whatever you put your mind, your heart, and your spirit into creating.
ReplyDeleteIt does seem like they always ask writers the same questions. That's just lazy, poor interviewing skills. And I bet writers get tired of giving the same answers.
Crossing over from real life into fiction sometimes takes a bit of craziness. Maybe people don't talk about it because they just don't know where the line is drawn. Or written.
ReplyDeleteDifference? What difference?
ReplyDeleteI know that I'm not the same as the other me. Maybe I'm the fake.
ReplyDeleteGut. I'll simply hang around this blog as long as it takes.
ReplyDelete*hang*
Hmm...the fact of the matter is the writers ultimately write about what and who they know. The craft comes in trying to disguise this.
ReplyDeleteI love the last line—"Also, I am a real person."
ReplyDeleteHi huni. . .As our ole journalist teacher said it takes 80% inspiration and 20% persperation. . .without that plenty of wasted screwed up pieces of paper. (thank god for the computer. . .ha!!).
ReplyDeleteTc have a g8 weekend. . .do you guyz have a Bank holiday too? We are having g8 weather. . .off to make the most of. C u next week same blogg. . . Xx